NOTE: this description my differ slightly from the "Items", as this description represents a later, slightly edited version. 1/4” stack. S. F. Coffman [Samuel Frederick Coffman, “Fred” Coffman] (1872-1954) was an prominent bishop living at Vineland, Ontario, influential in various leadership roles of the “Old” or “MC” Mennonite Church denomination. The roles included membership on the Historical Committee and of the Peace Problems Committee of the (MC) Mennonite General Conference, where he worked with Bender. He was a grandson of prominent Virginia bishop Samuel Coffman and son of prominent Mennonite “Quickening” evangelist John S. Coffman. {1} H. S. Bender to S. F. Coffman, March 4, 1939: on arranging an itinerary for Goshen College Men’s Chorus to sing in Ontario during Eastern vacation; details. • • • CONTIGUOUS, H. S. Bender to S. F. Coffman, “Rev. Jesse B. Martin”, and C. F. Derstine [Clayton F. Derstine], March 9, 1939: about the chorus trip--send some “girls” also, for a “mixed chorus”, as Goshen had in Illinois and Ohio? --a decision for Ontario people to make. {2} S. F. Coffman to Bender, April 5, 1939: on plans to be in Goshen for an appointment; had been ill and doctor had ordered “less strenuous life”; Charles Shoemaker [Charles B. Shoemaker, C. B. Shoemaker] had stopped by at Vineland, said that Mennonite Publishing House had $50 for use of the Historical Committee, and reported about “the Golden Rule Book Store” [later Provident Book Stores??] TWO} H. S. Bender to S. F. Coffman, April 1939 {3} H. S. Bender to S. F. Coffman, April 6, 1939: writing confidentially about possibility of an MC Mennonite being appointed pastor of Sterling Avenue Mennonite Church in Kitchener; enclosing a self-explanatory letter (apparently from a “Brother Snyder”); Bender had written to A. J. Steiner [Albert J. Steiner, Albert James Steiner] inquiring whether his son James Steiner might be interested; for this, probably “Sterling Avenue people would need to change a few things”; would be complications involving Ohio Mennonite Conference vis-à-vis Ontario Mennonite Conference if James Steiner were to be ordained; another possibility might be A. H. Leaman of Chicago [A. Hershey Leaman]. • • • REPLY, S. F. Coffman to Bender, April 22, 1939: saw that situation as “a most difficult one”, indeed impossible regarding Conference relationships; the person who had written to Bender was one of the conservative ones, but “there are some extremely liberalistic sections in the group” who “make it extremely difficult for any one of our ministers to cooperate and fellowship with such; the group had asked for some teaching, and Coffman and Derstine had discussed the request, but being a minister would involve upholding orthodoxy at baptism and communion, etc.; the congregation itself seemed to be ”somewhat at a loss” to know how to proceed, as between materials from Bluffton and from Goshen , etc., and Coffman thought they would have to solve their own problem; Coffman would keep Bender's letter confidential. {4} H. S. Bender to S. F. Coffman, April 27, 1939: had Coffman’s telegram [not extant here] that he would be arriving at Scottdale Tuesday 10 a.m. [i.e. May 2] just when Bender would arrive; suggested they proceed to home of John Horsch and the three of work together until noon, then meet with brethren from Publishing House in afternoon. {5} S. F. Coffman to Bender, May 4, 1939: had arrived home; was enclosing “program of the conference to be held by the German Brethren at Winkler Manitoba on May 15; hoped Bender could attend and help unify testimony of Mennonite churches in Canada and United States [?? regarding military draft, selective service system, conscientious objection, pacifism, nonresistance, Civilian Public Service, alternative service ??]. • • • CONTIGUOUS, H. S. Bender to S. F. Coffman, May 23, 1939: writing to report on the Winkler meeting; surely it was wise for “one of our group to attend” and the “Lord’s definite leading”; glad to report near unanimity among all nine branches present regarding nonresistance [pacifism]; had been some sentiment for a resolution on alternative service [[military draft, selective service system, conscientious objection, pacifism, nonresistance, Civilian Public Service]; “there seems to be a rallying of forces among our people on this question...”; even Hutterites had been present; Bender proposed that there be such a meeting in Ontario, perhaps “after the Mission Board meeting in [Fairview] Michigan”. TWO ENTRIES: H. S. Bender <--> S. F. Coffman, October 26, 30, 1939 {6} H. S. Bender to S. F. Coffman, October 26, 1939: at meeting with Quakers and Brethren [Friends; Church of the Brethren; Historic Peace Churches] in Chicago, had learned of a need certainly interesting to “the non-resistant relief organization of Ontario of which you are the chairman--a Quaker in Toronto named Raymond Booth was working to care for German Jewish and “non-Aran” [sic, non -Aryan] refugees and was pleading for churches to help; Bender had suggested to Friends they get in touch with Coffman; Bender had spoken to Orie O. Miller about going to Ontario but Miller had no time; Bender would come to “Hamilton or Toronto to represent our Relief Committee” to help “you”. • • • REPLY, S. F. Coffman to Bender, October 30, 1939: had Bender's letter and cheque from J. C. Frey [surely Jacob C. Frey]; had copy of a letter of Balderston [Robert Balderston, Robert W. Balderston] to G. Raymond Booth; this week Booth had come to Coffman’s home, a pleasure; details of what was being done with the children; L. J. Burkholder [Lewis J. Burkholder] was now president, and Coffman had referred the matter to him.... • • • REPLY, H. S. Bender to S. F. Coffman, November 2, 1939: had written to Burkholder; etc. [L. J. Burkholder; Lewis J. Burkholder] {7} H. S. Bender to S. F. Coffman, April 23, 1940: A. J. Metzler [Abram J. Metzler] had named Bender and Coffman to find a speaker for Friday evening, for subject “The Beginning of the Other Teaching Agencies”; Bender suggested Edward Yoder, or John C. Wenger [J. C. Wenger] as substitute [probably Mennonite Church Historical Committee work?]. {8} S. F. Coffman to Bender, February 8, 1941: committees of General Conference were to report; Coffman proposed that Bender, as Secretary, report on Historical Committee; Coffman would not be able to come to Committee meeting to be held with Mennonite Board of Education meeting. {9} H. S. Bender to S. F. Coffman, June 15, 1941: Bender was to be in Ontario next Saturday for choosing “two nurses for work in England” and wished to meet with Coffman; would like to meet with executives of “the nonresistant organizations” [historic peace churches?] and had invited C. F. Claassen to come [sic, surely C. F. Classen, Cornelius F. Classen]; proposed meeting at Hamilton instead of Kitchener. {10} S. F. Coffman to Bender, July 9, 1941 [stationery of “Non-Resistant Relief Organization”--names listed suggest it was an organization only of Mennonite branches, not historic peace churches]: had been working on getting “volunteer nurses for England, had a response from Edna Hunsberger of Kitchener, 29, graduate of Kitchener hospital, highly recommended; mention S. Goudie, vice-president of the organization [probably Samuel Goudie, Mennonite Brethren in Christ minister]; reference to working with a department of government with responsibility for nurses for England. {11} S. F. Coffman to Bender, August 5, 1941: had Bender telegram [not extant here] saying transportation was available for nurses, asking if Edna Hunsberger were approved; had sent telegram [not extant here] that the organization had approved her but was waiting for government permit; explanations. Ted Claassen [Theodore Claassen??] was available as a speaker in Ontario in week of October 20...; be sure to include Russian Mennonites; mention Orie O. Miller helping make arrangements. {12} H. S. Bender to S. F. Coffman, October 21, 1941: about Bender and Orie O. Miller having misunderstood arrangements about Ted Claassen meeting with the Non-Resistant Relief Organization on October 29; “We have received final word” from Ottawa ministry that “no Canadian woman will be granted permission to go to England,” so that ended “our endeavors in that direction”; had word that “10 Mennonite young men in Manitoba have been imprisoned as conscientious objectors”; C. F. Classen [Cornelius F. Classen] would be going to Ottawa to work for their release; seemed very strange, as Canadian law provided exemption for COs. TWO} S. F. Coffman to Bender, November-December 1941 {13} S. F. Coffman to Bender, November 10, 1941: would not be able to attend Historical Committee meeting (apparently set for December 5). • • • CONTIGUOUS, Note, S. F. Coffman to Bender, December 9, 1941: would try to be at the Historical Committee meeting on December 23. {14} H. S. Bender to S. F. Coffman, May 21, 1942: “We” were planning an important meeting of ”the American Section of the Peace Committee” [surely MC church’s Peace Problems Committee--PPC--U. S. Section] at Akron [surely Pennsylvania], May 28, and would like to have Canadian(s) present; hoped “at least one of you come.” {15} H. S. Bender to S. F. Coffman, April 27, 1943: sending galleys of Must Christians Fight [Must Christians Fight: A Scriptural Inquiry, by Edward Yoder, in collaboration with Jesse W. Hoover and Harold S. Bender (Mennonite Central Committee, 1943)]; invited suggestions. {16} H. S. Bender to S. F. Coffman and Edward Yoder, July 14, 1943: “As custodian of the archives” (surely on behalf of the MC denomination’s Historical Committee) [Archives of the Mennonite Church USA], Bender was distressed at very little progress organizing them this year; proposed engaging John C. Wenger [J. C. Wenger] for a week of work on them, aided by “an advanced student”, Roy Roth, for a total of 100 hours. {17} H. S. Bender to S. F. Coffman, October 8, 1943: Bender planned to attend Historic Peace Churches [HPC] conference at Waterloo on the 14th, would like Coffman to meet his train at Hamilton--then return him to Hamilton for travel on to Washington. TWO ENTRIES: S. F. Coffman to Paul Erb, May 20, 1944, and document {18} Copy, S. F. Coffman to Paul Erb [initialed “Guy F H” and “HSB” (Guy Hershberger, Guy F. Hershberger)], May 20, 1944: [a key letter in the founding of Mennonite Community magazine and eventually Christian Living] “Replying to your invitation to a meeting to discuss the farm paer [sic--surely paper]”; Coffman went on to give his vision and rationale for it--we already had papers that were religious and covered church work, and needed one “which will emphasize and maintain the industrial, financial and domestic life and culture which has been a part of our Mennonite life....”; and more--e.g., concern about Mennonites “finding their culture from sources which do not respect” Mennonite principles “of life and religion,” so that Mennonites would become “more and more estranged from the principles and practices ... of our forefathers”; was enclosing sheet outlining the publication. • • • ATTACHED, a sheet, headed with title “MENNONITE FARM AND FAMILY” and indicating coverage of Farm, “problems in the light of our principles, instead of New Deals Etc.” [political; welfare state]; Domestic Life, Industrial Life, Health, Social Life, Parent Problems; Farm News and Markets; Exchange Page. {19} S. F. Coffman to Bender, July 10, 1944: handwritten full-page letter obviously on occasion of Bender's ordination--tone of commendation and word from an elder, an older brother in the church. {20} H. S. Bender to S. F. Coffman, January 26, 1945: thanks for January 20 letter [not extant here] with suggestions for revising “Father Horsch’s History” [John Horsch]; Bender agreed “with your criticisms” but could not say how well “we” could carry out Coffman's suggestions. / Enclosed find materials regarding MCC’s [Mennonite Central Committee] proposed booklet on conscription [military draft, selective service system, conscientious objection, pacifism, nonresistance, Civilian Public Service, alternative service]; please go over it and offer criticisms; needed was “the history of Mennonites and conscription in Canada” with evaluation--could Coffman suggest sources? {21} H. S. Bender to S. F. Coffman, April 8, 1946: Mennonite Life was “not the fulfillment of the plans which were developed earlier within our group”; it was solely the product of “the General Conference people” working “independently of ours”; plans for our own journal [Mennonite Community magazine] were progressing--Scottdale [Mennonite Publishing House] having recently made a commitment to publish the first issue in January 1947, with Coffman on the Board of Advisors”; cc to Guy F. Hershberger. {22} S. F. Coffman to Bender, April 22, 1946: neither Coffman nor “A. L. Fretx” [probably A. L. Fretz, A. Lewis Fretz] could attend the Peace Problems Committee [PPC] meeting; the issues were mostly U.S. ones, but as members of a committee of the church’s general conference we should have a voice; “I am in favor of” maintaining the established standards which governments at least knew, even if they failed to understand [military draft, selective service system, conscientious objection, pacifism, nonresistance, Civilian Public Service, alternative service]; Coffman favored a service program in peacetime [Voluntary Service], not only a program to be ready for war; the program “Canadian Fellowship Service”, of the Historic Peace Churches, should have consideration although perhaps “worked out on a different system” [ecumenism, separatism?].